Yin wants to know if the Education minister’s vision for an education will tackle the challenges of the 21st Century – an outwardly looking and liberal education which teaches critical thinking , producing well rounded achievers
Of all the ministries the Ministry of Education has attracted the most attention – even more than the Ministry of Finance.
First, Dr Mahathir Mohamad appointed himself but withdrew when the public reacted negatively. Then he appointed Dr Maszlee Malik who also drew flak because of his religious leanings.
Education is so close to the hearts of Malaysians that everyone has an opinion on how to make it better. The minister is not short of unsolicited advice. In the New Malaysia citizens are not afraid to voice their opinions and this is a good thing. But whose two cents should the minister take.
Advice ranges from emulating the Finland model, implementing meritocracy, de-racialising academia including the appointment of vice chancellors, bringing back English and so on.
We are certainly not ready for the Finland models – our society is not that educated to accept it.
But the bottom line is Malaysians want an education system which prepares their children for the challenges ahead – in finding a job especially.
However the truth is parents are not ready for real change. Already if their children do not get homework they wonder why? And as to extracurricular activities they think it is a waste of time.
This is largely due to the system we have which is exam based.
Parents and teachers must realise that good universities now select their intake not on exam results only but also the applicant’s involvement in other activities and on the oral interview.
If I may say so, the present crop of high performers (the multiple As achievers) are distinctly mediocre – having spoken to many. They know very little else other than what they studied. They don’t show the natural curiosity of intelligent people. I put this down to the education system we have. What chance do they have in getting into good universities overseas?
How good our students are also depends on the teachers but when the teachers are products of the same system what can we expect? I was told of a teacher teaches English who has only read Mills and Boon. Sigh.
And what about filling in the blanks and multiple choice for teaching English?
“Mission Schools” model
While we are not ready for the Finland model perhaps we can bring back the “Mission Schools” model which we know. Schools then had a large measure of independence (within the government guidelines) and they produced students with character and ability. Perhaps we can go back to an updated version of this with changes to fit into our present circumstances.
As for our universities and colleges it is important to liberalise the intake and not let it be based on race. When colleges are exclusively Malays it reinforces the racial divide which spills into the working lives – how do these students deal with a multi-racial work environment? How do they learn empathy and appreciation of other cultures?
Our universities will remain the apex of mediocrity as long as lecturers and vice chancellors are appointed on race and not merit. Good universities attract academics and even vice chancellors from other countries – not just locally – but which academic will come here if we have a ‘close-shop’ and closed mind? You want world class universities then employ world class people and pick students on merit.
Exclude politics and religion
Remove politics and religion from education. While we should always promote our national language and insist on students learning our country’s history, this should not be politicized. It’s shameful that our history is rewritten to fit into the political narrative of the party in power. And if we want to progress and engage internationally then we must be proficient in English. No more should we become the laughing stock of the world when our former Deputy Prime Minister, Zahid Hamidi, addresses the United Nations in incomprehensible English.
The minister of education has a tough balancing act. He has the national chauvinists with their xenophobic tendencies, the religious establishment which insists on a generous dose of ‘agama’, teachers and lecturers who do not want change because their jobs are at stake, and parents who think the role of teachers is to coach their children to obtain multiple As. – not to develop their minds and character.
There are enough experts to advise the minister but that is not the problem.
The question is what is the minister’s vision for an education that prepares our young for the challenges of the 21st Century – an outwardly looking and liberal education which teaches critical thinking , producing well rounded achievers and not rote learning or an inward looking narrow education. Does he have the political will to take our education in a new direction or does he appease the ulamas and chauvinists.
It’s not easy being the minister of education.
(The views expressed are those of the contributor)
Letters from Ward 5, Tanjong Rambutan
If a job has to be done than it must be done right. It can only be done right if the right man is chosen to do it. And the right man maybe yellow black or green. It does not matter. Things go awry when the wrong person is asked to do the job. Square pegs in round holes. Quote – Tan Sri Ahmad Nordin (Rtd Auditor General)
The rot started in the early 70s with the initiation of the NEP. From then on it has been a slide down. What is the situation now? Students do not need to pass exams. If you fail you will still get pushed up. So after some time, there are no more exams. No point having exams if you still get promoted and worse of all leave school with a certificate, and even worse, get pushed into matriculation, then university and finally leave with a degree. Sure the percentage of Malay youths going to university is very high, compared with other countries. But what have they learned. Very little. As a result they are not fit for employment in the private sector. Only the govt. can absorb them. The above are true for government schools and public universities only. This is very sad for one who has observed the situation deteriorate from day one. Can we stop the rot and reverse the trend? Yes, but the will to do so must come from the Malays themselves because this affects mainly the Malays. Can they get out of the privileged mindset, and start to compete with everyone? How can they do it! For 60 yrs. they have been fed propaganda that they are the chosen one to succeed and acquire instant wealth. Now you tell them no more privileges. Work like everyone else. Why should they. They see millions of Malays with great wealth and “pangkat”,as a result of the NEP. Now they have to slog like s–t. How do you think they feel. These young minds are easy prey for politicians who feed on the insecurities and greed. So how do you solve the problem?