We have not only a failed government, but also a failed democracy!

By P. Ramakrishnan

We have a government that has failed.

We have a Parliament that won’t sit.

We have a democracy that doesn’t work.

This leaves the suffering Malaysians in the lurch.

We have a government that desperately wanted an emergency to tackle the Covid-19 and bring it under control. Armed with the emergency and the enormous powers under the Emergency Ordinances, this government had, nonetheless, failed to bring the pandemic under control. Indeed, the Covid-19 has spiralled out of control during the emergency which has been in force for nearly seven months.

This government is more keen in consolidating its powers and entrenching itself at the expense of the welfare of the nation and its people. It is a government that is unable to solve our problems with sound planning and effective policies. It is a failed government.

We have a Parliament that stands out as a majestic building and as a symbol of our democracy. This is where the peoples’ voices and grievances are articulated and their aspirations and hopes are uttered. But Parliament is unable to meet.

We have a Speaker who obstructs Parliament from functioning in a democratic way. He rejects motions submitted, rules queries need not be answered immediately and tells elected people’s representatives that their questions would be answered a week later on the following Monday, 2.8.2021. But on Sunday, the scheduled sitting of Parliament on Monday was cancelled. It all appeared like a well-planned plot falling into place, thus frustrating the democratic process.

The recent spate of signed letters from Umno MPs withdrawing support for the Prime Minister has clearly established the fact that the PM doesn’t have the majority support in Parliament, contradicting his bogus claim that he has. And yet there seems to be no mechanism requiring him to disclose the numbers and names to provide solid proof that he is the legitimate PM. Democracy is unable to move forward.

With the Covid-19 infected Malaysians soaring dangerously beyond the 20,000 mark today, 5-8-2021, with this threatening development screaming for urgent action to save Malaysia, we have a situation where the fragile position of the government receives the utmost attention to remain in power – not the danger posed by the pandemic. This seems to be the time for corruption and bribery to win over support for the PM. When the nation’s health and the people’s security are crying for priority attention and focus, democracy doesn’t seem to have a role to play in ousting these selfish characters from office.

In defiance and showing indifference to the plight of the jobless and the homeless, the PM appointed the Bersatu deputy president Ahmad Faizal Azumu today as his special adviser with the status of minister.

We already have the biggest cabinet in the world and we wonder how necessary is this one more minister to fight the Covid-19 pandemic successfully. It is going to cost the tax payers extra money to pay the salary and the perks that come with the position for the newly minted minister. This move is to consolidate the PM’s position through inducement. This is how democracy is being abused by this failed government.

Surprisingly, the PM receives the royal assent to subject himself to a vote of confidence only in September when the urgent need for that vote to be taken is now. There is provision in the Standing Orders for Parliament to be reconvened immediately without the 28-day notice.

Why doesn’t democracy allow this provision to operate for the convening of Parliament? “Dialogue is the essence of parliamentary politics,” as rightly pointed out by prominent Indian legislator Sharad Pawar. But they are preventing this dialogue by shutting down Parliament.

Some years back, Aliran organized a fund-raising dinner with the theme ‘People First, Democracy now’. This should become our rallying cry in our attempt to oust Mahiaddin:

People First, Democracy Now!

A failed government has forfeited the right to govern Malaysia.

Let’s listen to Aristotle who said, “They should rule who are able to rule best.”

(The views expressed are those of the contributor and do not necessarily reflect the views of Rebuilding Malaysia.)

6 August 2021

P Ramakrishnan is the long-serving former president of Aliran who served three and a half decades on its executive committee, and has been with Aliran since its inception in 1977. Now an ordinary Aliran member, he continues to highlight issues of public interest to a larger audience.

(Photo credit FMT youtube video)

Rebuilding Malaysia


  • Paul Wolfobitch says:

    “… but also a failed democracy!”

    Rather tough to see where our “democracy” is, have we got a democratically-elected monarchy?

    Not that I am necessarily against monarchy, anything, even a bunch of monkeys qualified with crap degrees from our crap universities would be more capable, definitely more interesting than anything called a “gomen” here.

    • Paul Wolfobitch says:

      Come to think of it, we also had a “democracy” where a secretive cabal of unelected “eminent persons” (wtf!) were foisted on the voters.

      A dictator decided who was “eminent” and the “eminent” decided they were “eminent” too, took to doing for the country whatever we never knew about, priceless!

  • alec says:

    You have aptly put the issues. Since TSMY has not given the YDPA proof of supporting MP, should not DYMM YDPA decline all further appointments by TSMY until he obtains the CONFIDENCE VOTE in Dewan Rakyat. DAULAT TUANKU.

Leave a Comment